Between the saffron and scimitar
On my other weblog I have a post, On The Instrumental Uses Of Arabic Science, which reflects on the role that the idea of science, the Islamic world, and cultural myopia, play in our deployment of particular historical facts and dynamics. That is, an idea, a concept, does not exist on an island but is … Continue reading “Between the saffron and scimitar”
On the instrumental uses of Arabic science
A new piece in Aeon, Forging Islamic science: Fake miniatures depicting Islamic science have found their way into the most august of libraries and history books. How? is quite rich food for thought. The nuts & bolts of the story are interesting enough, but perhaps the bigger picture is the emergence of (to borrow a phrase) […]
The Muslim intrusion into India was probably inevitable
Taking after Edward Gibbon it is often stated in some histories that the Islamicization of Europe was probably prevented by the defeat of the Muslim armies coming up from Spain by Charles Martel at the Battle of Tours. This is probably wrong for several reasons. First, with hindsight, it seems clear that people like to … Continue reading “The Muslim intrusion into India was probably inevitable”
Perhaps India is not special in resisting Islamicization
I have posted my thoughts as to why India, unlike Iran or Central Asia, resisted total Islamicization, before. It seems to be a phenomenon that demands an explanation. And yet does it? As I read F. W. Motte’s Imperial China 900-1800 I am struck by Han civilization’s resilience and absorptive capacity. What does that remind … Continue reading “Perhaps India is not special in resisting Islamicization”
The Quran as a collective human enterprise
When people ask about my religion I usually just say I’m an atheist and I have no religion. If they continue, I usually give them what they want, and state my parents are Muslim, or I am from a Muslim background (most of the time the people asking for what it’s worth are themselves Muslims, […]
The Muslim world stands upon the shoulders of the Ummah
The two plots above are from a new working paper, On Roman roads and the sources of persistence and non-persistence in development. The basic argument is that good Roman infrastructure correlates with modern patterns of prosperity. An ingenious way the authors tested the predictive power is to contrast Europe, where carts and therefore roads, remained […]
The “clash of civilizations” is a thing, just not the only thing
A few days ago I put up a post, The “Islamic World” Was Not Invented By Europeans. Since then, I have been reading the author’s book, The Idea of the Muslim World: A Global Intellectual History. It’s an interesting work with a lot of facts. Though so far no facts have been surprising to me, and, […]
On the semiotics of secularism and nakedness of village atheism in the culture war
Listening to the lovely bells of Winchester, one of our great mediaeval cathedrals. So much nicer than the aggressive-sounding “Allahu Akhbar.” Or is that just my cultural upbringing? pic.twitter.com/TpCkq9EGpw — Richard Dawkins (@RichardDawkins) July 16, 2018 One of the great celebrity “village atheists” of our day, Richard Dawkins, has “stepped in it” again by eliciting […]
India as the hydra against Islam
In some versions of the legend of the Hydra, every time you cut off one of the heads of the monster two more grow in its place. I have been thinking about why and how India remained predominantly non-Muslim despite most of the subcontinent being under Muslim ruling for 500 years (dating from 1250 to … Continue reading “India as the hydra against Islam”
Crescent over the North Sea
Pew has a nice new report up, Europe’s Growing Muslim Population. Though it is important to read the whole thing, including the methods. I laugh when people take projections of the year 2100 seriously. That’s because we don’t have a good sense of what might occur over 70+ years (read social and demographic projections from […]
The question should be “Who Are Salafi Muslims and Why Are Many So Extreme?”
Because of the horrible massacre at a mosque with Sufi tendencies in Egypt, there are a lot of “explainers” out there about sectarian divisions in Islam. The one in The New York Times, Who Are Sufi Muslims and Why Do Some Extremists Hate Them? could be worse. This portion especially gets at the major issue: […]
The rise of “orthodox” Sunni Islam in Indonesia is inevitable
Curfews, Obligatory Prayers, Whippings: Hard-Line Islam Emerges in Indonesia: In the Indonesian market town of Cianjur, new rules require government workers to clock in with their thumb prints at a downtown mosque to confirm attendance at morning prayers. That’s on the order of district chief Irvan Rivano Muchtar, who also wants a 10 p.m. curfew […]
On the Rohingya issue
I have a post over at my primary blog, Rohingya Unmasking Complexity In A World We Want Simple. Because the Rohingya issue is going to be in the media spotlight for a bit in the near future we need to be clear about the deep historical facts, which frankly the press is going to not … Continue reading “On the Rohingya issue”
Arab Islamic science was not Arab Islamic
Someone stupid who follows me on Twitter said “It seems @razibkhan forgot the Arabs gave us algebra and many other scientific/mathematical advances.” The history of algebra is actually somewhat more antique than the Arabs, as outlined in Unknown Quantity: A Real and Imaginary History of Algebra. But the origin of the word is Arabic. From […]
Democracy leads to Islamism
The New York Times has a piece up on the rise in Islamic extremism in the Maldives, Maldives, Tourist Haven, Casts Wary Eye on Growing Islamic Radicalism. I want to highlight one section: It was governed as a moderate Islamic nation for three decades under the autocratic rule of the former president, Maumoon Abdul Gayoom. […]
The issue is how you experience Islam
Sadiq Khan: This sickening act has nothing to do with the Islam I know: To murder innocent people, especially during Ramadan, is a rejection of the true values of my religion. Since religion is made up I’ll take Khan’s assertion at face value and not dispute them. The aspect that people like Khan are not … Continue reading “The issue is how you experience Islam”
Islam in China is not one
Over the past few days I have seen articles in the media which refer to “Chinese Muslims,” and then make such a casual and slight distinction between Muslims in China and the Uyghur ethnic group that I think it’s really misleading to the general public (e.g., Anti-Muslim sentiment is on the rise in China. We found […]
Modernity is not magic with Muslims
There are many reasons I have become very skeptical of the media over the years. Though I do not subscribe to the conspiracy theory paradigms, it is obvious that the mainstream media often combines fidelity to precise narratives with a lack of detailed knowledge about the topics they are covering. In other words, they’re stenographers […]
What is Europe’s anti-Semitism problem about?
In Slate, Europe Has a Serious Anti-Semitism Problem, and It’s Not All About Israel: A recent Anti-Defamation League survey found that 24 percent of the French population and 21 percent of the German population harbor some anti-Semitic attitudes. A recent study of anti-Semitic letters received by Germany’s main Jewish organization found that 60 percent of the hate mail came from […]
Burma’s “Muslims” are kalar Bengali
The American media often confuses the subtleties of international ethography. For example, there is a tendency to use the term “Uyghur” and “Chinese Muslim” interchangeably. This is misleading. The largest Muslim ethnic group in China are the Hui, who were … Continue reading →